Big bore cartridge recommendations

Did you get the Black Widow that was on GB last week? Hope so, beautiful, perfect pistol. I almost bid on that myself.
For bigger Reeder revolver cartridges and a full custom gun, look at the 510GNR.
For bigger bore guns on a budget, there's the Magnum Research BFR in 475 or 500 LB, those could benefit from Gary's Positive Performance Package.
Ruger Bisley Super Black Hawk in 480 Ruger is another good option.
If the UBW is your first Reeder gun, welcome to the club!

option would be a .480 Ruger Bisley.

The 500 S&W is you’re most versatile option. It can be loaded down to a very comfortable plinker or loaded hotter than any of the other cartridges. Bullet selection is far better with a huge range of bullet weights available and brass is easy to find. The BFR and X frame are both capable and affordable platforms.

Here’s an example of one of many choices available. I won’t argue for or against but simply say I truly enjoy this gun. Loaded with Trail Boss, it is a pleasure and of course things can easily go up from there.

can see from the replies there are many opinions and LOTS of experience from a variety of handgun hunters. I have shot all of the cartridges mentioned and at the age of 75 am finding that the recoil is becoming an issue with me because of arthritis in my hands and fingers. I do have a Reeder 510 Hunter that I have carried for many years in the field in Alaska. I shoot both the short and long GNR 510 rounds and have killed hogs with both. The short round doesn't kick quite as much and the long has a little more with a little more punch. A day at the range and about 25 rounds or so is all I can handle. I don't know if that is an issue with you but it should be considered. I shoot the 350 grain loads S & L from Gary's reloading manual. The bullets can be found at Montana Bullet Works. They are really great people there and can get you the bullets you want or you can do like several on here do and cast your own. The people on here that cast can give you a lot of information even if you are experienced in casting. I have 475 LB in an Encore and brother that sucker kicks! Not many of those and I call it quits. BUT, for a hunter it will knock down anything you are liable to encounter. For paper cutting not so much. Good luck in whatever your decision is and once again welcome.

Is my dream gun, It just looks right and would be the coolest to carry. That said, 475 Linebaugh loaded to its potential, is the most i can take. I usually use IMR 4227 mid range cast bullet (375 gr) loads.
You my not be a 64 year old arthritic handgunner, so you may want more (or less) than what is usable for me.

Can shoot 460 Sw / 454/ 45 Long Colt. Would be sweet in one those stretch frames.

- No text -

The .510" bullets are limited in jacketed options, cast are available but not as many in 350 gr. and less, best suited to revolvers. The brass is also expensive, and you did mention economy. Rather oxymoronic with big bores.

The .500" cal. guns have a wide array of bullets in all styles available and brass is a little easier to fine. Still not inexpensive but more available. I like the idea of a shorter, .500 LB length, true .50 wheelgun. The .500 S&W is too much for me unless you just want one.

For me I really liked the .475 LB, also shoots .480 Ruger. Lots of bullet options galore, brass too. I'm leaning a bit in this direction.

.454 is a step above the .44 Mag. and has all the vicious recoil you'd like for paper punching. Being able to shoot .45 Colt is a bonus. It's kind of nice to have one around.

Bro. Jim's suggestion of a .41 cal. is an interesting one if the opposite direction of your inquiry.

Gary's .510 is what I'm sticking with right now. A slightly shorter .500 LB basically and easier to download. Having .510 on the side of your gun makes it stand out, even beside a .500 LB gun! The brass is expensive but lasts forever. I shoot cast almost exclusively but know where to get a couple jacketed options if I wanted them. I like the unique and exclusive, I seek it. It's your choice and your fun.

Lee Jurras' last gun, a .475 LB.

Have at it!

Gorgeous, if I wasn't saving for my Alaska trips I would have bid hard for this.

sweet package deal on. E mail me if interested jdt66030@yahoo.com