Food for thought
Trace Hatfield
[subject]
Saturday, January 18, 2025, 13:39 (556 days ago)
Would it be possible to make a revolver in 17 caliber (17 hornet),(17 hmr). Just wondering what everyone thinks. Also bored from the horrible weather in the northeast.
I’ve shot .17 HMR handguns a bit
WB
[subject]
Saturday, January 18, 2025, 20:24 (555 days ago) @ Trace Hatfield
TC and single shots mimic rifle accuracy and ballistics. Soda cans at 200 yds. pretty easy with 2500-2600 fps. It also mimics the trajectory of my .378 GNR, good for practice.
I’ve had several Taurus Tracker revolvers. 8” run 2200fps, the 6” does 2100. I get 1”-2” groups at 50 yds. Still have an iron sighted 6”. They are about like a k-frame chassis and 7-shot.
Found a pic of my Taurus
WB
[subject]
Saturday, January 18, 2025, 21:53 (555 days ago) @ WB
![[image]](images/uploaded/20250119045114678c84c298c9a.jpg)
I stand corrected on the velocity. The 8” was 200 fps faster than the 6-1/2”. That’s what this one is I believe.
The most redeeming feature of the .17 rim-fire
WB
[subject]
Sunday, January 19, 2025, 07:59 (555 days ago) @ WB
Is that it does not ricochet at all, the bullet comes apart when it hits anything. That’s good when you have a neighbor a few hundred yards away. Or you are shooting at high angles at squirrels etc. Plus a handgun with 2000 fps shoots flat!
.17 K-Hornet
AlanT
[subject]
Sunday, January 19, 2025, 12:42 (555 days ago) @ Trace Hatfield
I remember asking Gray about doing a .17 K-Hornet in a Blackhawk back in 2003-04; right after Hornady & Ruger introduced the .17HMR. I figured it would be faster and, since it was re-loadable, more economical using the centerfire cartridge.
At the time, Gary said he wasn't interested in taking on the project.
Smaller than .22 present unique challenges
WB
[subject]
Sunday, January 19, 2025, 19:00 (554 days ago) @ AlanT
I’d like to see some work done with the .204 caliber. The bullets are light but heavier than .17. One issue I had with the .224-32FA was bullet construction. I used a 40 gr. Nosler Varmint bullet at 2100 fps and it mostly just ice-picked on through the small Muntjac. Remember Hornady figures they may be shot at 4000 fps plus by most users! Maybe it was poor placement. He wasn’t being still for me.
In .22 cal. I liked the 30 gr. Calhoun bullet which expanded better. Honestly the best performing bullet was my home cast 45 gr. with a home fabricated hp tip.
But the Hornady .17HMR provides .17 Mach2 ballistics from a revolver, which performs well to 100 yds. or so.
The 17 caliber anything poses a lot of problems
Gary Reeder
[subject]
Monday, January 20, 2025, 12:17 (554 days ago) @ AlanT
Steve Hornady was and is a good friend and asked us to build the first 17 caliber handgun they had come out with. I must have tried every twist barrel made by man trying to make that thing accurate. Finally I gave up on the project. Later on Steve told me they had accidentally given me a rifle chamber reamer and there was really no way to make that gun accurate. Steve said when they went to a revolver chamber reamer the problems went away. But fighting that 17 caliber revolver was more than I ever want to do with a 17 caliber.
Ruger made a Single Six 17 Hmr for a while
Derek
[subject]
Monday, January 20, 2025, 07:31 (554 days ago) @ Trace Hatfield
- No text -
There's one at an LGS
Howard
[subject]
Monday, January 20, 2025, 08:07 (554 days ago) @ Derek
There's a stainless Single Six in 17 HMR with scope at the East Hartford, CT Cabelas. It doesn't appear on their Used Gun website list. I'll post a pic and details if anyone's interested.
I am going to bet it is one of the Hunter models
AlanT
[subject]
Monday, January 20, 2025, 09:46 (554 days ago) @ Howard
Ribbed 7.5 inch barrel; with integral scope mounts.
It should come with a second cylinder in .17 HM2.
They were built @ 2004.