open carry for Jewish people ?

Joepjs
[subject]
Friday, May 23, 2025, 14:55 (429 days ago)

Since it has become open season on Jewish people in DC, can it be inferred that Jewish people are allowed open carry or unlicensed carry to defend themselves?

At this rate, it should be mandatory....

JFS
[subject]
Friday, May 23, 2025, 17:57 (429 days ago) @ Joepjs

- No text -

To me open carry

TM
[subject]
Thursday, May 29, 2025, 09:30 (423 days ago) @ Joepjs

is an invitaion to be shot first.

And it only intimidates people who are not a threat.

Blake
[subject]
Thursday, May 29, 2025, 16:01 (423 days ago) @ TM

- No text -

Being targeted for OC..a dissenting opinion

plowboysghost
[subject]
Friday, May 30, 2025, 07:51 (422 days ago) @ TM

..is exceedingly rare, versus how many people targeted every single day who aren't open carrying?

I've had this discussion countless times (almost exclusively online) over the last 12-13 years that I've (mostly) open carried (in 34 years of carrying altogether) a properly holstered sidearm without incident.

What I've found is that some people (almost all of whom have never open carried as a civilian) have strong feelings against OC that aren't based in real data..and that depart from consistent logic.

Most of us believe that NO GUNS signs and "gun free zones" invite targeting those businesses/schools/etc... Most of us would probably agree that posting GUN FREE HOME signs in your front yard might invite home invasions/robbery/etc..., yet some of those same folks are fine with appearing as weaker/unarmed prey in a world of assailants who obviously target non open carriers/seemingly unarmed folks at a rate of likely greater than 99.-something percent to probably less than 1 percent.

It can be argued that some places are inhabited by people and groups of people that are more likely to try their luck than other places, and I'd agree. Of course, those places and people aren't safe for non open carriers or unarmed people, either...as statistics will prove.

With that said, OC isn't for everybody. Too many people walk around distracted. Open Carry requires a heightened sense of situational awareness, a strong dedications to personal responsibility, and secure holsters.

In 12-13 years of mostly OC, the ONLY negative comments I've ever heard were from three different women, two of whom had northern accents. One told me (when asked by me) she was from Illinois. I told her that if she felt safer in Chicago with all their anti-carry laws that she was welcome to hit I-65 North, anytime). The other wouldn't say what state she was from.

Most people here have apparently learned that someone pushing a grocery buggy around the store who just happens to be have on a properly holstered handgun isn't cause for panic and mass hysteria. Open Carry hasn't led to more violence/targeting, etc.., as the ant-2A groups now going after Open Carry in certain states/areas are claiming.

Plowboy while I certainly support your opinion, I

jthomson
[subject]
Saturday, May 31, 2025, 08:48 (421 days ago) @ plowboysghost

live in an open carry state, and very rarely see anyone exercise that right. As you might guess I do live in one of the western states where everyone is carrying open during hunting season or round-up LOL. I personally view the matter as one of privacy, NUNYA nunya business if I am armed or not, the very first thing I want you to see is bang if I must draw on you. So just personal preference, I certainly do take note when I see someone who is carrying open. so for that fact, it does increases my awareness.

I too live in an open

TM
[subject]
Saturday, May 31, 2025, 21:06 (421 days ago) @ jthomson

carry state. I think I have seen less than 5 people open carrying in the last 10+ years. In the city people just don't do it. They just want to go unnoticed and not advertise themselves as a target.

"advertise themselves as a target"..

plowboysghost
[subject]
Sunday, June 01, 2025, 21:11 (420 days ago) @ TM

I strongly (!) disagree that OC makes people more of a target than being seemingly unarmed. I believe that the daily violent crime stats favor my argument...overwhelmingly.

OK, but why increase the odds?

TM
[subject]
Monday, June 02, 2025, 07:29 (419 days ago) @ plowboysghost

- No text -

It doesn't....

plowboysghost
[subject]
Monday, June 02, 2025, 12:08 (419 days ago) @ TM

The arguments against OC remind me a WHOLE lot of the arguments the antis make against carry altogether.

They said that concealed carriers were "far more likely to be shot with their own gun". That false statement made sense to those who were fearful or genuinely ignorant of the reality of it, but the statistics clearly disprove that.

Here, back in 2013 when Alabama clarified that OC has always been legal here and laws were passed to prevent open carriers from being harassed/ charged with disturbing the peace/etc... for simply open carrying, the banshees on the Left wailed that more blood would run in the streets and children would be caught in shootouts in the toy section at WalMart.

The sky didn't fall then, either.

I'm sure that if I had never open carried (which isn't always OPEN "on display" so much as it is "carried where I can get to it without having to dig it out in an emergency" ) that I would be apprehensive about it, or if I lived/operated in a place surrounded by thugs that I would adjust for it.....but I've open carried for 12 years (everywhere that it's legal from the Gulf Coast of Alabama to Kentucky to Lincoln, NM) of my 34 years carrying ( + - )and I wouldn't operate/ live in places surrounded by thugs.

Do what works for you where YOU are, in the manner YOU are comfortable with. Best of luck to you.

OK, but I'm not

TM
[subject]
Tuesday, June 03, 2025, 12:41 (418 days ago) @ plowboysghost

taking any chances, regardless of whom I am around.

10-4

plowboysghost
[subject]
Tuesday, June 03, 2025, 20:20 (418 days ago) @ TM

Best of luck to you however you prefer to carry.

Open or concealed...your choice. BUT, definitely carry!

Derek
[subject]
Saturday, May 31, 2025, 17:10 (421 days ago) @ Joepjs

- No text -

powered by my little forum