Regarding Gary’s 45acp conundrum...

Drdougrx
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 05:22 (2633 days ago)

I’ve often wondered about the issue of penetration and the 45acp. I switch between a one of Gary’s PDs and a Shield45 cause it’s legal in the 2 states that I spend most of my time in.

I like light weight, small autos. I’ve looked at the current line up of 10mm guns and find LW and small don’t quite fit the 10mm genre.

I have a Colt GM converted to 460 Rowland. Decisive cartridge to be sure! I took a large rambolett at HHC with it and it hits really hard for sure. But it has a comp and is way too large for a CCW. Is a lighter, faster bullet in 45acp of different construction the answer? Like an extreme penetrator or some hot 45acp? Should we carry a solid flat point of some design??Maybe convert a LW commander type pistol into a 45super? Or really change it up and convert a 1911 into a 357sig.

I’m thinking that I’d like to try a lot of these on hogs at HHC....me thinks live flesh and blood would tell us more than the jello shooters.....

What do you think???

I've seriously considering adding a Glock 29...

Huey
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 05:37 (2633 days ago) @ Drdougrx

I like the TC FMJ Bullets too. Offers a good balance of penetration and knockdown. The WFN works the same as Gary's Flattop Tool.

Glocks are simple. You pull the trigger and a bullet is leaving the barrel.

Another odd thought...400corbon?

Drdougrx
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 05:50 (2633 days ago) @ Huey

- No text -

No.

WB
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 06:36 (2633 days ago) @ Drdougrx

- No text -

here we go with my opinion again. You can go to

Gary Reeder
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 13:04 (2633 days ago) @ WB

the fridge and get a beer while I expound on my never ending opinions. I would stay away from gimmick cartridges. By that I mean the 357 Sig, the 440 Cor Bon, the 460 Rowland, the 45 Super, and any of the gimmick loadings. Cops like to talk praise about the 357 Sig as they were brain washed at the academy by their instructors. But I have talked to quite a few cops that say they have had failure to feed problems with it unless they have a 2 handed death grip on it. And that makes sense. And cops have more of a chance to be in a gunfight where they don't have 2 hands on the gun, so there is a chance of the misfeeding.

The Rowland and Super are good cartridges but both have a lot more recoil than normal and again unless you have a good two handed hold on the gun the recoil could easily tend to make you lose the grip on the gun for that needed second or third shot and cause a stovepipe situation. My simple recommendation is stay with a simple hard ball round. Sight your gun in with it and stay away from the gimmick stuff.

10mm 1911 Commander, whatever make is my choice

Rsim
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 06:29 (2633 days ago) @ Drdougrx

I have two: Ruger SR1911/10mm and I splurged for a Nighthawk Custom Commander/10mm. I shoot the Nighthawk often. Best accuracy of any handgun I've ever shot, bar none. Ammo: Magtech 180gr. TMJ, never a problem.

Ball or Jhp

Ayoob
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 07:03 (2633 days ago) @ Drdougrx

My home is 95% of my self defense, at my age

Rsim
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 09:31 (2633 days ago) @ Ayoob

(65), street is not where I spend much time. After sundown, I'm home or in a group of 4 or more, at least two of us carry. But that's just me and mine. Here in FL, houses have poured concrete walls, it's cooler and severely limits any collateral damage...

Keep the gun change the ammo to Underwood 45 Penetrator.

AndyS
[subject]
Saturday, June 15, 2019, 10:11 (2633 days ago) @ Drdougrx

You won't be disappointed.

powered by my little forum